Mysteries You Can Never Solve Such as a Good God and Evil

God. A good God. Evil. A world. A world made by God. A world made by a good God. A world made by a good God has evil in it. What gives?

I’ve been slugging back and forth on an atheist’s blog concerning this topic, and I’m not sure if continuing to post and answer the challenges are worthwhile.

Not because I feel defeated. Not because I have a weak position. It’s just that I have a position that requires a first hand encounter with God. Everything I say can be torn apart without that connection with God. Let me ‘splain.

Instead of asking questions that we’ll never know the answer to, such as, “Did God create evil?” or “If God is all powerful, why doesn’t he stop evil?” let’s begin with what we can say with reasonable certainty.

God made the world.

God said the world was good.

God made men and women and intended to live with them.

Somehow a lying serpent ends up on the scene and tempts humans.

The men and women defied God and a mess was created.

The men and women of the world kept making it worse.

God tries again and again to make it better, but humans usually hold things up.

Good so far? We can’t say for certain whether God intended this to happen or whatever. Taking the narrative of Genesis as close to face value as I can, we see a good God making a good world, but the good world turns against him.

So somehow evil got into the mix. Now, we don’t know how that happened, but we do know that God himself came to earth (if you are a Christian that is!) and died to liberate humanity from sin. That’s where the death, resurrection, and eventual return of Jesus comes in.

OK, now, think about this. God is clearly not powerless against sin and evil. That’s what the resurrection shows (once again, I’m coming at this from a Christian perspective).

God is fighting against evil. In fact, he has beaten it, but not eradicated it. So, for some reason, evil is still hanging around. We don’t know why God permits things to be so, and it’s hard. Death, deceit, etc. all are painful and take their toll on us.

Nevertheless, as a Christian I can look at Jesus’ death and resurrection as a sign that God is working against evil. The ministry of Jesus that continues today is the beginning of God’s new reign that will once again come to earth.

I cannot explain why there is evil in the world or why it continues in the presence of a good and loving God. What I can say is that God has done something, is doing something, and will some day do a lot more.

Perhaps it becomes more bearable if we think of this time as temporary. This life is not the ultimate goal. God’s thinking on a grander scale. Perhaps that explains some of the Apostle Paul’s optimism about the temporary suffering in this world.

Technorati Tags:

5 thoughts on “Mysteries You Can Never Solve Such as a Good God and Evil

  1. Adam Malliet

    Here is where I expose myself as a heretic… I believe that Open Theism has a good answer to question of evil…

    God created a world in which having a relationship with His creation was His utmost desire. This required a genuine give and take, which required granting libertarian free will. He created a world in which He had every reason to believe that man would not turn from Him and evil would never enter the world. (we don’t know how long man lived with God in this planned harmony, perhaps millions of years, we only know that he eventually fell) However, it was a possibility and so God took a risk.

    I’ll not be dogmatic about this interpretation, but I believe it has merit and can be very helpful to the analytically minded.

    Unlike Process Theology, I believe it can be scripturally supported, you know if that’s your thing, its mine, but probably not your atheist friend.

    Its logical, for those days when you need it to all make sense… I have those days, less and less though.

    Most importantly, it isn’t nearly as absurd and horrific as Calvin’s ridiculous claims that God is creator, maintainer, and purveyor of all evil.

  2. Adam Malliet

    oh man, what a terrible typo… just terrible… Atheist Friend, yikes… geez

    Can you fix that Ed ?

  3. Ed Post author

    All better. I was going to e-mail you to find out if you meant "friend."

    I think open theism is worth checking out. I mean, don’t we live pragmatically that way even if our doctrines say something different most of the time? Can I call myself a practical open theist? Maybe. I’ve gotta think more about that one.

  4. Adam Malliet

    Most Christians are pragmatically speaking, open theists. This is what matters.

    If your interested in studying the theology behind it, shoot me an email and I’ll recommend some books.

  5. nate

    Adam, you beat me to the punch. I was going to post on open theism yesterday(but as you know I left the office early).

    Ed, that’s the camp I fall into as well…definately worth checking out. Would love to have a face to face with you and Adam on this topic sometime in the future – when’s the next time you’ll be home? (Did you like how I called NJ home?)

Comments are closed.