I like to think of myself as a pretty reasonable person. I arrive at logical reasons for what I do and believe, and I’m even kind enough to share them with others, expecting them to follow along.
I’m reasonable, that is, unless I’m not.
A few years ago my family wanted to go on this big kayaking and camping trip. The forecast was for rain, but we went anyway. I remember thinking that it was going to be a huge disaster.
It rained the whole drive up and during our first paddle. The whole time I kept thinking how doomed we were. It was raining during our camping trip! How terrible! I mean, we were surrounded by water, and it was terrible to get wet by water that wasn’t in the lake, right?
Then the rain stopped and we had wonderful weather for the rest of the trip. I had a great time camping out on an island because we didn’t have to worry about bears quite as much, though I’m sure they can swim, and kayaking has to be one of the most relaxing ways to see a ton of scenery.
And who can resist the call of a loon in the night?
I thought that I was so reasonable to doubt the success of our trip. It was quite humbling to realize how wrong I had been. I would have missed out on a great adventure if I’d been my stuck in the mud self and stayed at home.
I’m reasonable with lots of other things, but they’re all different from my judgment about the kayaking trip. I’m pretty sure that I’m right about this stuff. I’m a reasonable person who comes up with reasonable beliefs and practices.
So when I dabble with something like, say, theology, I can come up with all kinds of reasonable explanations that describe God. I have a reasonable God who makes lots of smart decisions.
Come to think of it, God must be a lot… like… me.
Since I like dabbling with this theology thing, here’s a thought:
What if God reveals himself to me as unreasonable?
In other words, I’m not saying that God could be wrong. I’m saying that I could be wrong about God. I could create standards for God that I believe to be reasonable, only to discover that I was wrong.
Can I still worship a God who doesn’t fit my own criteria for what is reasonable? What if I’ve created an image for God in my theology that doesn’t actually reflect the character and nature of God?
We could take this in a bunch of directions. We could get philosophical and talk about what it means for God to change or to not change. We could get personal and talk about issues like pain, evil, salvation, the Kingdom of God, and even homosexuality.
What will conservative Christians do if they find out that God welcomes people that they pegged as outsiders or those deemed to be living in sexual sin?
What will liberal Christians do if they find out that God really will punish those who refuse to believe and that certain sexual lifestyles are not acceptable in his sight?
Theology can only take us so far. We’re dealing with approximations at best when we talk about God. We can study the Bible all we want, but at the end of the day we’re just talking piles of dust and spit trying to define a deity that we can only see in a mirror dimly.
We know some things about God, but as NT Wright says, we can’t be 100% sure that all of our beliefs are right. And if we one day discover that God is different from us, what will we do?
I don’t think you can blog a rebuttal after standing before the judgment seat of God. Actually, I’m pretty sure about that one.
At a certain point we bump into our limitations and the likelihood that we have been wrong about God in some ways. We have to decide whether we’re willing to stick with God even if he dashes parts of our theology to bits, even if he appears unreasonable, intolerant, or too inclusive.
This is why Christianity is about more than an idea or a belief. Christianity is about an encounter with the living God. I’m talking about those moments when the hair rises on the back of your neck because you can sense God’s presence and hear him speak to you.
Our theology helps us seek God out, but at the end of the day, our time in God’s presence where we hear from him make up the substance of daily discipleship for all of us. When Jesus speaks of the final judgment, his criteria is whether we knew him. I for one am glad that I took my last theology test in seminary.